Over $400 billion lost annually – enough to eliminate extreme poverty worldwide
By Jason Cianciotto
Too frequently the daily news includes stories about discrimination and violence perpetrated against LGBTIQ people around the world. The images may range from bruised and bloodied faces in Jamaica, to men being thrown off buildings in Iraq to the reported 689 murders of transgender people in Brazil from 2008 to 2014, reflected on a map from Trangender Europe.
Civil society organizations like OutRight Action International, formerly the International Gay and Lesbian Human Rights Commission – have spread global advocacy to assert the human rights of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender and intersex populations for over 25 years. Yet, it was not until 2008 that the United Nations General Assembly discussed LGBTI rights. In the proceeding years, with persistent advocacy, there has been steady progress. Most recently a December 10 forum honoring Human Rights Day focused on the cost of LGBTI exclusion- co-organized by OutRight and Human Rights Watch as NGO members of the coalition of 18 countries known as the UN Core Group, along with the UN Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights.
For the first time ever, the president of the General Assembly addressed a U.N. forum on LGBTI issues. In opening remarks, H.E. Mogens Lykketoft made it clear that members states are obliged to protect the human rights of LGBTIQ people.
“As you know, not all members of the General Assembly, see eye to eye when it comes to questions of sexual orientation and gender identity…At the same time, no member state can deny that it is legally bound to ensure that all people enjoy their human rights without discrimination – and this includes discrimination against those who are lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender,” Lykketoft said. “Regrettably, we still have a long way to go before LGBT people … are able to live their lives free from fear or harassment; free to contribute to their society like any other person. …We know what States need to do to change this reality and address these abuses:
- Repeal laws that criminalize people for being gay and transgender;
- Put in place anti-discrimination laws that penalize anyone who discriminates against people because of their sexual orientation and gender identity;
- Educate people… to respect one another, no matter the differences that distinguish us one from another.”
He continued, “Taking steps such as these will enable member states to enrich people’s lives. It will see them fulfill their international human rights obligations and… help them to reap significant economic dividends.”
The forum, “The Economic Cost of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Exclusion,” focused on a World Bank report by economist Dr. M.V. Lee Badgett. The report quantifies the cost of workforce discrimination, increased health costs, and anti-LGBT laws, which can cost a nation up to 1 percent of its Gross Domestic Product.
Applied globally, a conservative estimate of this impact (0.05 percent) amounts to over $400 billion – enough to eliminate extreme poverty globally – a preeminent goal of “The United Nations 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.”
Dr. James Heintz, economics professor at the University of Massachusetts, Amherst, explained some of the factors included in Dr. Badgett’s analysis, which can lead to reduced GDP for homophobic and transphobic nations:
- Anti-LGBT discrimination in the workplace lowers the productivity of LGBT people, which lowers the contributions their labor makes to the economy.
- LGBT people who live in homophobic and transphobic nations experience more negative physical and mental health outcomes, which increase health care costs to society.
- LGBT youth who experience harassment and violence in school and/or at home are more likely to drop out and become homeless, often during a critical transition to adulthood. This reduces their potential productivity for the rest of their lives.
- Anti-LGBT laws carry an economic cost of enforcement, diverting resources that could be used to increase the productivity of the economy.
- International investors and businesses are less willing to invest in a country that does not support fundamental human rights for all people.
These fundamental factors were further explained in a new video released at the forum by the UN “Free and Equal” campaign, titled The Price of Exclusion,
OutRight that day released the final video in its “Cost of Exclusion” LGBTIQ Africa series focusing on the same issue.
-Dr. Heintz emphasized that while Dr. Badgett’s findings will provide additional support for U.N member states to change their anti-LGBT laws and policies, there is intrinsic value to protecting the human rights of all people, regardless of economic consequences.
Panelist Kasha Jacqueline Nabagesera, director of Freedom and Roam Uganda, put a face to the economic data. Through sharing her own personal story as a lesbian living in Uganda, Kasha highlighted personal economic effects, such as the cost of repeated evictions from home and long-term unemployment, and the affects on families, many of who need to flee their country in order to be safe.
Kasha challenged decisions by nations and humanitarian organizations to reduce international aid or boycott Uganda or other nations based on homophobic laws and policies. “That causes a backlash to our community,” she said, “if you single out such a group of society as a condition to suspend aid.”
Rather, Kasha encouraged other tactics to hold governments accountable while supporting LGBTIQ populations, such as through direct connections to civil society. “For example, most of us human rights defenders are here today because of OutRight Action International” she said. “Try to work with some of our partners in the West to support us on the ground.”