The U.S. Supreme Court Wednesday ruled that section three of the so-called “Defense of Marriage Act” is unconstitutional and that the federal government cannot discriminate against married lesbian and gay couples for the purposes of determining federal benefits and protections. Wednesday’s ruling is a historic victory for gay and lesbian Americans and a tremendous step forward for the cause of equality.
The court’s ruling said: “The history of DOMA’s enactment and its own text demonstrate that interference with the equal dignity of same-sex marriages, a dignity conferred by the States in the exercise of their sovereign power, was more than an incidental effect of the federal statute. It was its essence.”
The justices ruled in favor of Edith “Edie” Windsor, who sued the federal government for failing to recognize her marriage to her partner Thea Spyer after Spyer’s death. Windsor, a software programmer at IBM, and Spyer, a clinical psychologist, met in the 1960s. Spyer was diagnosed with multiple sclerosis in 1977, and Windsor helped her through her long battle with the disease, which eventually left Spyer paralyzed. Windsor and Spyer, who were a couple for 44 years, were married in 2007. Their love was documented in the film Edie & Thea: A Very Long Engagement.
In the film about their life together, directors Susan Muska and Gréta Ólafsdóttir presented a lovingly crafted documentary in which the two woman reminisce about how their improbable romance ignited a lifelong journey around the world and has, through Edie’s victory over DOMA, cemented their story as a classic.
Though they were touched by events like the civil rights movement and the Stonewall riots, Edie and Thea’s relationship also transcended politics and continues to serve as a shining example of love’s ability to endure.
Ultimately, with both women in their 70s and Thea’s health in decline, the two decided it was time to fulfill their dream of getting married. The film captured their inspiring journey to Toronto – and Thea’s last trip on a plane – where the women were finally able to make their vows. Told with candor, wit, and great affection, Edie & Thea: A Very Long Engagement is an American love story for the ages. The film is available at all major retailers, including Amazon and on Netflix streaming.
When Spyer died in 2009, she left all of her property to Windsor, including the apartment that they shared. But because DOMA prevented the federal government from recognizing the marriages of gay people, Windsor was forced to pay $363,000 in estate taxes that she would not have owed if she had been married to a man. Windsor’s attorneys argued that DOMA denied her, and other gay and lesbian married couples, the equal protection of the law guaranteed by the U.S. Constitution.
“DOMA violated the fundamentally American principles of fairness and equality,” said Windsor. “Because of today’s Supreme Court ruling, every child born today will be able to grow up in a world without DOMA – a world where the federal government won’t discriminate against their marriages no matter who they are. I know Thea would have been so happy and proud to see how far we have come in our fight to ensure that all gay and lesbian couples are treated with the dignity and respect that they deserve.”
“This historic ruling recognizes how unfair it is to treat married lesbian and gay couples as though they’re legal strangers,” said James Esseks, director of the American Civil Liberties Union’s Lesbian Gay Bisexual Transgender Project. “Edie and Thea were there for each other in sickness and in health like any other married couple. It’s only right for the federal government to recognize their marriage and the life they built together.”
“This is truly a day for the history books, one that will be marked by future generations as a giant step forward along our nation’s continuing path towards equality,” said Roberta Kaplan of Paul, Weiss, who argued Windsor’s case at the Supreme Court. “DOMA was the last law on the books that mandated discrimination against gay people by the federal government simply because they are gay. The days of ‘skim milk’ or second-class marriages for gay people are now over.”
“Today, the Supreme Court reinforced its commitment to the promise of ‘Equal Justice Under Law.’ This is a great day, and a reminder that when individual citizens like Edie Windsor have the courage to stand up for their rights, they can achieve fundamental change,” said Pamela Karlan, co-director of the Stanford Law School Supreme Court Litigation Clinic.
“This is a great day for equality and the beginning of the end of official discrimination against people who are lesbian and gay,” said Donna Lieberman, executive director of the New York Civil Liberties Union. “We are delighted for Edie and for families across the country.”
Both a federal district court and a federal appeals court ruled in Windsor’s favor previously.
The complete court decision can be read here.