Public Says Women are Equally Qualified, but Barriers Persist
According to the majority of Americans, women are every bit as capable of being good political leaders as men. The same can be said of their ability to dominate the corporate boardroom. And according to a new Pew Research Center survey on women and leadership, most Americans find women indistinguishable from men on key leadership traits such as intelligence and capacity for innovation, with many saying they’re stronger than men in terms of being compassionate and organized leaders.
So why, then, are women in short supply at the top of government and business in the United States? According to the public, at least, it’s not that they lack toughness, management chops or proper skill sets.
It’s also not all about work-life balance. While economic research and previous survey findings have shown that career interruptions related to motherhood may make it harder for women to advance in their careers and compete for top executive jobs, relatively few adults in the new Pew Research survey point to this as a key barrier for women seeking leadership roles. Only about one-in-five say women’s family responsibilities are a major reason there aren’t more females in top leadership positions in business and politics.
Instead, topping the list of reasons, about four-in-ten Americans point to a double standard for women seeking to climb to the highest levels of either politics or business, where they have to do more than their male counterparts to prove themselves. Similar shares say the electorate and corporate America are just not ready to put more women in top leadership positions.
As a result, the public is divided about whether, even in the face of the major advances women have made in the workplace, the imbalance in corporate America will change in the foreseeable future. About half (53 percent) believe men will continue to hold more top executive positions in business in the future; 44 percent say it is only a matter of time before as many women are in top executive positions as men. Americans are less doubtful when it comes to politics: 73 percent expect to see a female president in their lifetime.
These findings are based on a new Pew Research Center survey of 1,835 randomly selected adults conducted online November 12-21, 2014. The survey also finds that the public is divided over whether a woman with leadership aspirations is better off having children early on in her career (36 percent) or waiting until she is well established (40 percent). About one-in-five (22 percent) say the best option would be to not have children at all.
Getting the Job Done in Politics and Business
When it comes to characteristics that apply specifically to political and business leadership, most Americans don’t distinguish between men and women. But among those who do draw distinctions, women are perceived to have a clear advantage over men in some key areas.
Political compromise has been in short supply in recent years, particularly in Washington, DC. Many adults (34 percent) think that female politicians are better at working out compromises than their male counterparts. Only 9 percent say men are better. A narrow majority (55 percent) say there’s no difference between men and women in this regard.
Women are also perceived to have an edge over men when it comes to being honest and ethical (34 percent say women are better at this; 3 percent say men are better at it). Women have a somewhat narrower advantage over men when it comes to working to improve the quality of life for Americans and standing up for what they believe in despite political pressure. For both of these characteristics, solid majorities say there is no difference between men and women.
Just as in the political realm, the public does not see major differences between men and women on key business leadership qualities. Where they do see gaps, women have a clear advantage over men on honesty and ethics, providing fair pay and benefits, and offering mentorship to young employees. Men have an edge when it comes to being willing to take risks and negotiating profitable deals.
Women in Leadership Today
As the 114th Congress gets underway, a record number of women (104) will be serving in the House and Senate. Today women make up 19 percent of the Congress, about double the share from 20 years ago. Progress has been slower on the corporate front. Only 26 women are now serving as CEOs of Fortune 500 companies – roughly 5 percent. In 1995 there were none. Women are slightly better represented in corporate boardrooms than they are at the CEO level. As of 2013, about one-in-six board members of Fortune 500 companies (17 percent) were women, up from 10% in 1995.
The pipeline for female leaders seems to be widening. Women have made significant gains in educational attainment in recent decades, better positioning themselves not only for career success but also for leadership positions. Since the 1990s, women have outnumbered men in both college enrollment and college completion rates, reversing a trend that lasted through the 1960s and ’70s. And women today are more likely than men to continue their education after college.
Women have also made inroads into managerial positions and professional fields in recent decades. In 2013, over half of managerial and professional occupations in the U.S. (52.2 percent) were held by women, up from 30.6 percent in 1968. Even so, women continue to lag far behind men in senior management positions.
Gender and Party Gaps in Views on Female Leadership
For women, the issue of having more female leaders goes far beyond equality in the workplace. Four-in-ten of them (38 percent) say having more women in top leadership positions in business and government would do a lot to improve the quality of life for all women. An additional 40 percent of women say this would have at least some positive impact on all women’s lives. For their part, men are less convinced that female leadership has such wide-ranging benefits. Only 19 percent of men say having more women in top leadership positions would do a lot to improve all women’s lives, while 43 percent say this would improve women’s lives somewhat.
When it comes to the barriers that may be holding women back from achieving greater representation in the top leadership ranks, women are much more likely than men to point to societal and institutional factors such as the country not being ready to elect more female political leaders and women being held to higher standards than men in business and in government.
Women are also more likely than men to say that female leaders in both politics and business outperform male leaders on most of the traits and characteristics tested in the survey. The gender gaps in perceptions about political leadership are especially sharp. Whether on compromise, honesty, backbone, persuasion or working for the benefit of all Americans, women are more likely than men to say female leaders do a better job. For their part, solid majorities of men say there aren’t major differences between men and women men in these areas. Nonetheless, they are somewhat more likely than women to give a nod to male leaders over female leaders on four of the five political leadership qualities tested in the poll.
Those who identify with the Democratic Party, which dominates the ranks of elected female leaders at the federal and state levels today, also have more favorable impressions of the women who serve in leadership positions in government and in business.
When it comes to political leadership, Democrats are significantly more likely than Republicans to say that women do a better job than men on each of the attributes tested in the poll. For their part, Republicans are not necessarily more likely to favor men in these areas, but they are more inclined to say there isn’t any difference between men and women.
Democratic women in particular are strong proponents of female political leaders. In most cases, they are more likely than both Democratic men and Republican women to say that female political leaders do a better job than men.
Democratic women are also among the most enthusiastic about the possibility of having a female elected as president. As Hillary Clinton weighs another run for the White House in 2016 and progressive groups urge Elizabeth Warren to get in the race, 38 percent of all adults say they hope the U.S. will elect a female president in their lifetime; 57 percent say it doesn’t matter to them. This compares with 46 percent of Democratic men, 20 percent of Republican women and 16 percent of Republican men. To be sure, for many Republicans this view may be more about the prospect of a Hillary Clinton presidency than about a major milestone for women, a perspective that likely influences the way they respond to this “hypothetical” question.
The remainder of this report examines the current landscape of women in leadership in the U.S. and the public’s views on this topic. Chapter 1 lays out trends in female leadership in elected political office and in corporate America, as well as changes in the pipelines to top leadership positions. Chapter 2 looks at public attitudes on men, women and key leadership traits in both the political and business realms. And Chapter 3 explores the obstacles to leadership for women, as well as views about discrimination and the future of female leadership.
Other Key Findings
Women are far more likely than men to see gender discrimination in today’s society.
About two-thirds (65 percent) of women say their gender faces at least some discrimination in society today, compared with 48 percent of men who believe women face some discrimination. A double-digit gender gap on perceptions of gender discrimination is evident across all generations as well as across partisan groups.
Women and men are seen as equally good business leaders, but gender stereotypes persist.
Most Americans (54 percent) say men would do a better job running a professional sports team, while just 8 percent say women would be better at this. And a 46 percent plurality also give men the edge when it comes to running a large oil or gas company. But the public is two and a half times more likely to say a woman, rather than a man, would do a better job running a major hospital or a major retail chain.
Young adults are more likely than older generations to say women with leadership aspirations might want to delay having children.
More than four-in-ten Millennials (46 percent) say a woman who wants to reach a top position in business is better off waiting to have children until she is well established in her career, while 29 percent say she should have children early in her career. By contrast, four-in-ten Boomers and nearly half (48 percent) of members of the Silent generation say it’s better for a woman with high-level business aspirations to have children early on.
Among partisans, Republican men are the most likely to say the country has taken the steps needed to achieve gender equality in the workplace.
About half of Republican men (54 percent) say the country has made the changes needed to give men and women equality in the workplace. By contrast about two-thirds (66 percent) of Republican women say more changes are needed. Even larger majorities of Democratic and independent women and Democratic men agree that gender parity is still a work in progress.
A Note on Generations
Some of the analysis in this report looks at adults by generation. While the definitions of generations can differ slightly among researchers, this report relies on the following standard Pew Research definitions.
- Millennials: born after 1980, ages 18 to 33 in 2014.
- Generation X: born from 1965 to 1980, ages 34 to 49 in 2014.
- Baby Boomers: born from 1946 to 1964, ages 50 to 68 in 2014.
- The Silent Generation: born from 1928 to 1945, ages 69 to 86 in 2014.